GIG HARBOR - When Brenna Peloquin was nominated to participate in the “ice bucket challenge” that supports donations for research into Lou Gehrig’s disease, she debated whether to participate. “I didn’t want to make waves,” she said.
Then the 18-year-old decided to do “something proactive” — make an ice bucket video to educate others and take a stand against embryonic stem-cell research.
“Lots of people don’t know what their money is going toward,” said Peloquin, a member of St. Nicholas Parish in Gig Harbor, adding that she was concerned when she read that embryonic stem cells are still used in some research into Lou Gehrig’s disease. Also called amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, or ALS, the disease attacks cells that control a person’s muscles.
In a fundraising challenge that spread like wildfire on social media this summer, thousands of people made videos of themselves being doused by buckets of ice water as a way to encourage donations for ALS research. The drenched nominate others to do the same within 24 hours, or make a donation to ALS research. The ALS Association said it has received more than $100 million in donations as a result of the challenge.
“A lot of money that is being raised through these videos is going towards the use of embryonic stem-cell research, which as a Catholic I am very much against,” Peloquin said in her video.
The issue arose in other Catholic quarters, which brought a response from the ALS Association. In an Aug. 26 release, the organization said it primarily uses adult skin cells for research, but does have one privately funded study that uses a line of embryonic stem cells established “many years ago.” Before the ability to use adult cells was developed, embryos were the only source of stem cells for research, the association’s website says, and “the ethical issues involved hindered development of this research.”
“ALS is a horrible disease that must be cured,” Peloquin said in the video that she posted to her Facebook page, and later to YouTube. “I’ve had a lot of family members and friends touched by ALS and I think that it’s great that everybody is coming together, filming this in order to find a cure for this disease and raise awareness.”
Her hope, she tells viewers, is that they will become aware of ALS, get educated about adult stem cells vs. embryonic stem cells, “and put their money towards adult stem-cell research over embryonic stem-cell research.” She encourages viewers to donate to the John Paul II Medical Research Center, which does not support embryonic stem cell research.
And finally, after challenging family and friends to do the same, she is doused with ice water.
Peloquin said she hopes her video will inspire other Catholics. Many of her friends had similar concerns about embryonic stem-cell research, she said, and their reaction to her video has been mostly positive: “I have had people thank me for making it.”
Learn about the John Paul II Medical Research Institute.
What the church says
Find links to church teachings, documents and more stem-cell research information at the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ website.
Ice bucket challenge brings attention to pro-life research center
By Mark Pattison
WASHINGTON - Few people think of Iowa City, Iowa, as a hotbed of medical research. But in a roundabout way more Catholics are beginning to take notice of a Catholic, pro-life medical research center.
This summer's ALS ice bucket challenge craze has netted nearly $100 million in donations for the ALS Association as celebrities and commoners alike are taking to social media, posting videos of themselves getting doused with ice-cold water (and sometimes ice cubes), and challenging four friends to do the same: Get an ice-cold soaking, make a donation, or both, all for the purpose of fighting amyotrophic lateral sclerosis or Lou Gehrig's disease.
But because the ALS Association has acknowledged conducting research using embryonic stem cells -- a practice opposed by the Catholic Church, and one the association said is funded by one specific donor and is coming to an end -- a few dioceses have recommended making donations instead to the John Paul II Medical Research Institute, which conducts ALS research without using such cells.
The institute focuses on developing core technologies that all diseases need, and doing this within a pro-life value system.
Compared to what the ALS Association is pulling in from the challenge, the institute's income thus far has been, well, a drop in the bucket, but it represents a 100 percent increase in donations.
"Last year, we raised $170,000 of private donations, primarily through word of mouth, people we know. Because we're small, we don't have an organizer for marketing, a professional fund-raising organization," said Dr. Alan Moy, who co-founded the institute in 2006 with his wife Jeanne.
"In the last 10 days, we've received exposure and that's doubled. That's pretty significant," Moy told Catholic News Service Aug. 29. "But compared to ALSA, that's peanuts."
The institute's website says that it saves money by being in the Midwest as opposed to either of the two coasts, and it doesn't pay huge salaries to its researchers. In all, according to Moy, there are 10 full- or part-time employees in all phases of the institute, including nonresearch tasks.
Moy said the findings of the research done by the institute would have applications for ALS as well as for cancer and other debilitating illnesses.
"Our model is what do we need to do that can reduce the time and money it costs to push a drug into a clinical trial," he said.
At the institute, as at Catholic hospitals, "there's a lot of people who may not be Catholic and they may not be pro-life, but they have to recognize that the hospital isn't going to do anything that's opposed to Catholic teaching," Mow explained. "They're going to have to abide by certain Catholic principles. As long as they know that, I want them to work passionately, work hard, and know what the end game is. ... People are interested in making a difference."
The institute takes credit for several accomplishments: helping facilitate the first commercial adult stem cells for medical research; helping facilitate achieving the world's largest repository of adult stem cells; helping facilitate the development of induced pluripotent stem cells, which takes a patient's cell and, through genetic manipulation, creates a stem cell that has all of the biological features of an embryonic stem cell but without the need to destroy embryos; creating technology to convert stem cells into neurological cells; creating a clinical infrastructure to recruit patients from private centers around the country with less red tape than found in academia and government.
Moy said many of the adult stem cells created at the institute have therapeutic potential for ALS.
The institute, which partners with Mercy Hospital of Iowa City to gain access to patients, has a plan -- contingent on continued increased donations -- to "scale up" its activities, Moy said. Elements of that plan include recruiting more ALS patients around the globe, collecting their clinical data, creating personalized stem cells from them, screening drugs on those ALS stem cells to find the best lead drug candidates for entering into clinical trials, manufacturing FDA-approved adult stem cells that could be approved for ALS clinical trials, and then participating in those trials.
Moy also hopes to double the institute's staff.
"The ice-bucket challenge created an awareness among pro-life individuals about ALS and the supportive position of the ALS Association towards embryonic stem cell research," Moy said in an Aug. 28 email to CNS. "With all of the attention given to this media phenomena, pro-life individuals just stumbled across the institute and decided to give us financial support to conduct research on ALS."
Catholic News Service - Sept. 2, 2014
Sept. 10, 2014